Click to view print spread (PDF)
The Play: The Technology
Finding the sweet spot
by Cheryl Hudak
One of the most valuable items in the natural gas toolbox is a unique method of exploration geophysics called 3-D reflection seismology. In the past 20 years, seismic vibrations have shaken up the natural gas industry, changed the exploration paradigm and opened new doors of opportunity to aggressive, unconventional operators like Cheseapeake Energy.
3-D seismic helps geoscientists explore layers of rock formations beneath the earth’s surface, seeking out structural traps that could contain hydrocarbons. By its most common definition, seismic data is a road map that leads explorers to the “sweet spot” which holds the highest potential for finding natural gas. Equally important, it helps avoid subsurface hazards and has greatly reduced the risk of drilling dry holes.
The 18-foot-wide stereo screen in Chesapeake’s
3-D Seismic Visualization room turns scientific
information into a giant virtual game board for
geoscientists.
Chesapeake’s 250-person geoscience team uses continually improving seismic data gathering systems and superior data interpretation skills to help the company attain an impressive 98% drilling success rate.
“The company is widely recognized as the nation’s most active driller for natural gas, with more than twice as many active rigs as the second company on that list,” said Larry Lunardi, Vice President – Geophysics, “But Chesapeake is even more weighted seismically, with 3-D seismic data covering more than 19 million acres – three to four times the seismic inventory of our closest competitor.
“That is extremely important to our success,” Lunardi said. “Because almost every time we look at a 3-D map of the earth, we discover something we did not expect – sometimes something we never dreamed was there. That’s pretty amazing.”
Vibrator trucks shoot sound waves deep into the earth.
Chesapeake has budgeted more than $300 million for seismic data in 2008. Most of this data will be acquired as proprietary 3-D surveys. “That means we pay for the survey and we have exclusive use of the findings,” Lunardi explained. “About 90% of our proprietary surveys are on properties that have never been shot before. Occasionally, we resurvey over an area where seismic was done some time ago. The difference is the improvement in technology.
“Today’s high-resolution seismic is much better defined and easier to interpret. It’s like the difference between conventional and high-definition television. Now we actually refer to some of our data as HD because its pixilation is analagous to that of HD-TV.”
3-D glasses enable scientists like Kurt
Schrantz, Senior Geophysicist, to envision
geologic formations miles below the surface.
Those high-definition images can be viewed most effectively in the company’s 3-D Seismic Visualization Room. In this unique facility, 3-D stereo eyeglasses turn natural science into what resembles a video gamer’s paradise on 18-foot-wide stereo screens: fault lines come to life, underground formations float like space stations, intersected by yellow poles representing possible drilling sites. It looks likes a virtual game board for natural gas exploration.
For anyone who might consider wildcatting a game, the ante is high. 3-D seismic helps even the odds.
“It tells us where to poke the $7 million hole,” Lunardi said with a smile.
The technology will continue to evolve. In some of the company’s earlier surveys, recordings were made using 400 channels of six geophones each.
“Nowadays we have 4,000 to 5,000 channels. Instead of a narrow swath of phones, we have an active patch 12 miles long and four to five miles wide. There is a huge difference in what you can see,” he added. “In the early days of 3-D, each pixel was equal to one seismic trace and we might have 30,000 to 40,000 traces in a square mile. Now we are recording more than a million traces in a square mile.”
Today’s seismic survey is not only more detailed than its predecessors, it is far more expensive. Terrain is a factor in the cost. In the wide-open spaces of West Texas and Oklahoma, where vibrator trucks can be hauled in to produce sound waves, costs are less than in locations with rough or mountainous terrain such as Appalachia, where shothole drilling equipment must be transported entirely by helicopter.
“We make surveys as large as possible because it’s more economical to survey per square mile,” said Lunardi. “Our average survey today is about 200 square miles. The per-unit cost is better with larger surveys, and you have a greater opportunity to find things you really didn’t know were there.”
Properly interpreted, such information is a roadmap to success in the natural gas exploration industry.
There is no doubt that 3-D seismic technology has enabled the company to create value in some of the nation’s hottest unconventional natural gas plays like the Barnett Shale of North Texas and the Fayetteville Shale in Arkansas.
Now the 3-D seismic road map is again expanding, as Chesapeake recently revealed important new unconventional natural gas discoveries in the Haynesville Shale of Lousiana and the Marcellus and Lower Huron Shales in Kentucky, West Virginia, Pennsylvania and New York.
How does seismic work?
Sound waves are shot deep into the earth by the use of vibrator trucks (vibroseis) or explosives. Magnetic recorders then note the length of time it takes for those waves to reflect back up to geophone receivers on the surface. This data is processed by specialized computer software, resulting in 2-D seismic profiles that can be interpreted to provide a cross section of the rock layers that form the earth’s crust.
Today, most seismic surveys use a two-dimensional arrangement of geophones and a two-dimensional grid of energy sources. This results in a three-dimensional image of the geology being surveyed – and it is called 3-D seismic.
History of seismic
Early seismic equipment was often mounted
on the bed of a pickup truck, such as this
one in the 1920s.
The concept of seismic is not new – Ludger Mintrop, a German mine surveyor, first proposed seismological methods for exploration and received a patent in 1916. The following year, a Canadian inventor named Reginald Fessenden was working on methods of detecting submarines during World War I, and he filed patents on a method to use reflected seismic waves to infer geology.
In 1920, John Clarence Karcher incorporated the Geological Engineering Company in Oklahoma, after he and colleagues from the University of Oklahoma came up with the idea that sound reflections Karcher had used to detect artillery might aid in hydrocarbon exploration. This technique was, in fact, originally referred to as the “Oklahoma” method for acquiring 2-D reflection seismic data.
After many decades of refinement, the use of seismology, which became more commonplace in the 1990s, is a prerequisite for the development of unconventional natural gas plays.
Heliportable seismic in Appalachia
Hovering over an imaginary grid, a
helicopter prepares to lower a shothole
drill over a seismic survey area in
Appalachia.
The rugged terrain of the Appalachian Basin makes it difficult to transport and position vibrator trucks to conduct seismic surveys. Steep mountain ridges and deep hollows provide uneven purchase for vibroseis trucks. In many forest areas, there are no roads to bring heavy equipment through the dense woods.
For two years, Chesapeake has literally risen above these problems by using heliportable equipment when it conducts seismic surveys in the challenging West Virginia environments.
“Because of the mountain terrain here, this is an environmentally friendlier way to accomplish seismic data gathering,” said B.J. Carney, Senior Geophysicist – Appalachia. “It leaves a smaller footprint because we don’t cut roads or haul in heavy trucks or equipment. Instead, we surgically drop drills between the trees with no loss or damage. There is no long-term effect on wildlife or farm animals.”
Heliportable seismic works this way:
First, a small shothole drilling rig is delivered by helicopter, attached to the end of a 160-foot cable. The 12- by 4-foot drill is carefully lowered into position and untethered from the hovering helicopter.
Second, a 20- to 40-foot bore is drilled and a small charge of explosives is set in the borehole. The helicopter then picks up the drill and moves it to the next drilling position. This is repeated until the area being surveyed is filled with a grid-like pattern of charge-filled bores – often 50 per square mile.
Next, a grid of geophone receivers is set over the entire survey area to record the reflection of sound waves. Fourth, radio signals trigger the explosive charges deep in the earth, to create the sound waves required for measurement.
“From this point, the process is the same as using vibroseis,” said Carney. “It is a very expensive process – about four times the cost of conventional seismic. Chesapeake is willing to push the edge of the envelope, taking more risk for higher rewards. And here in the Eastern Division, that is starting to pay off.”
Shaking things up, six years ago 3-D seismic
indicated the Buffalo Creek 1-17 might be a
success. To date, the well has produced more
than 50 billion cubic feet of natural gas.
A Success Story: Wildcatting at Buffalo Creek
The story of the Buffalo Creek 1-17 in Beckham County, Oklahoma, is a love song to seismic. Located in an area with no proven production, Chesapeake had access to nonproprietary seismic that indicated the location might have hydrocarbon potential. The well, spud May 14, 2002, was drilled to more than 21,000 feet in the Springer formation. Buffalo Creek 1-17 came out strong – at 45 million cubic feet per day (mmcf/d). Six years later, it is still producing 10 mmcf/d, with total production thus far of 51 billion cubic feet (bcf), one of the highest revenue-generating wells in the state’s history.
“One of the highlights of my career was being given the opportunity to design the completion of the Buffalo Creek 1-17,” said Michael Park, District Manager – Anadarko. “The Buffalo Creek 1-17 has just become one of 11 elite Oklahoma gas wells to have surpassed the 50 bcf production mark – and the only Springer well in Oklahoma to have done so.”
Park gives credit for the well’s success to many team members such as Richard Green, Geology Manager – Anadarko, and Geophysicist Tom Sharp – as well as to the availability of seismic data.
The company recently finished drilling a 22,000-foot wildcat near the location, using proprietary seismic from a new survey they fondly call “East Buffalo Creek.”