Click to view print spread (PDF)
The Play:
Oklahoma Dewatering Project
Cheryl Hudak
Chesapeake is noted for its expertise in finding and producing unconventional natural gas: gas that is trapped in shales or tight sandstone reservoirs requiring technologically advanced drilling and completion techniques. Today the company is raising the definition of unconventional to a new level as it removes tens of thousands of barrels of water each day from naturally water flooded oil and natural gas reservoirs in order to unlock gas reserves trapped in remote, highly permeable rocks previously believed to contain too much water to produce.
As the pressure is lowered, the dissolved gas
is released – a process similar to opening a
can of soda and allowing the carbon dioxide
dissolved in the soda to bubble up and out of
the can.
Called dewatering, this recovery concept was developed during the past 10 years by a group of independents in Oklahoma who had prospected for years in the Hunton formation. As they attempted to produce a well, they observed that reservoirs with trapped oil would see increased gas production as long as they continued to produce large volumes of water. Early dewatering projects by other operators took place in Lincoln County, Oklahoma, recovering primarily gas and sometimes additional oil.
Chesapeake started drilling its initial dewatering project in 2007, with first production of natural gas in March 2007 at the Davis pad northwest of Enid, Oklahoma. Today, the company has drilled eleven additional wells and is one of the more active players in the Hunton dewatering play. Chesapeake is also the dominant dewatering operator in the Simpson-Dolomite formation, a similar type rock, but with trapped gas in the reservoir instead of trapped oil like the Hunton.
Stretching east to west across the state, the Hunton lies between 5,000 - 15,000 feet below the ground and may be 500 feet or more thick at its southern edge. Farther north, the Hunton gets closer to the surface and thins out to as little as five feet thick. At a certain point in northern Oklahoma, it disappears altogether.
“We call that the “Hunton pinchout,” said David Craycraft, District Manager, Northwest Oklahoma. “And that’s where we are drilling – where the pinchout moves west into Alfalfa and Woods County – that’s the point along the line where some geologic process enhances permeability and allows us to bring up gas.”
Dewatering plays such as the Hunton and the Simpson-Dolomite require a specific geological environment, according to Bob Campbell, Sahara District Geoscience Manager. “For a dewatering play to work, the play usually has to be a carbonate formation of limestone and dolomite. That means the rock has to have high porosity and permeability in some places and low porosity and permeability in others.”
Chesapeake is one of the most active players
along the Hunton pinchout in northwestern
Oklahoma.
Eons ago, the larger pore spaces and natural fractures in the formation contained hydrocarbons. Then an ancient geologic event caused water to sweep through the reservoir and flood the larger, more porous parts of the rock, leaving oil and gas in the smallest, least porous parts of the formation. Both types of porosity have to be in place for the dewatering process to work.
Moving the gas to the wellbore is not easy.
Dewatering involves a “pod approach.” First a high-capacity saltwater disposal well is drilled down into the deeper Arbuckle formation, which can hold tremendous volumes of water. Then satellite producing wells are drilled into the Hunton formation in four adjoining sections. Some of these may be horizontal, others vertical or directional. Horizontals are usually around 12,000 feet in total measured depth while vertical and directional wells are around 7,000 feet deep. Flexibility is critical in the northern part of the pinchout, where the pay zone may be extremely small – ranging from five to 15 feet thick. In some places the pinchout is also the high point on the structure. So accumulations of oil and gas can be found up against the pinchout as well.
In the dewatering areas, water is pumped from the Hunton formation, up to the surface and then down into the disposal well. The trapped oil contains dissolved natural gas. As the pressure is lowered, the dissolved gas is released – a process similar to opening a can of soda and allowing the carbon dioxide dissolved in the soda to bubble up and out of the can. Continuing to lower pressure causes the gas to expand and it begins to flow through the reservoir with the water and up into the natural gas wellheads.
The distinction of a dewatering play from a typical, high water cut oil and gas field is this: in a dewatering play, as water is produced the reservoir pressure is also reduced, but at the same time the gas production and any associated oil increase initially. In a high water cut field, the water, pressure and gas deplete proportionately.
“Twenty years ago it wouldn’t have crossed our minds to produce these particular formations in this manner,” said Campbell. “Back then, when we found water in a project, we just moved on to something else. That is no longer the case. We shot 3-D seismic to mitigate risks and help define the geology.”
Challenges are part of the job, according to Campbell.
“It’s fun trying new things. If something doesn’t work, we learn from it and apply what we have learned to the next project. We get the resources and support we need and we have highly responsible people in the field who observe closely and help us find new ways to succeed.”
Dewatering plays are time-consuming, expensive operations. High-capacity pumps for water extraction are expensive, costly to operate and require additional power. Chesapeake works closely with local companies such as the Alfalfa County Electric Cooperative to upgrade the power systems.
The results are worth the cost and effort.
“When you find an ideal situation, you get very high production rates and large reservoirs of natural gas,” Craycraft said. “One of our dewatering wells is bringing up 5 million cubic feet per day (mmcf/d) from a 7,000-foot wellbore. We have greatly improved the concept and process and have a great acreage position,” he added. “We are poised for new development when the price of natural gas goes up.”